Court of Appeal of Zambia - 2020 December

8 judgments
Skip past years
Skip past months
Skip to results

Results. 8 judgments found.

8 judgments
December 2020
A consent order is ordinarily impeachable only by commencing a fresh action, not by application within the same proceedings.
  • Civil procedure — consent orders/judgments — impeachment of consent order — proper procedure is commencement of a fresh action; Obiter dicta v ratio — Paluku comments not binding; Functus officio — effect of sealing/endorsement of consent order; Order 42 Rule 5A (White Book) — endorsement/signature issues do not permit setting aside within same cause; Joinder of non‑parties before fresh action.
24 December 2020
Appellant's challenge to arbitral awards dismissed; awards held within arbitration scope and not contrary to public policy.
  • Arbitration — setting aside arbitral award — scope of submission to arbitration; public policy and ex turpi causa; strict rules of evidence vs substantial compliance; reliance and expectation damages; jurisdiction and arbitrability; intelligent guess quantification of damages.
23 December 2020
Whether a Certificate of Title can be cancelled for alleged fraud, tax under‑declaration, or non‑Zambian ownership eligibility.
  • Land law — Certificate of Title — Section 33 and 54 Lands and Deeds Registry Act — cancellation only on proved fraud or impropriety; Alleged tax under‑declaration is a matter for ZRA and does not alone invalidate title; Burden of proof on party alleging ineligibility of non‑Zambian purchaser; Admission of additional grounds in heads if respondent had opportunity to contest.
15 December 2020
Change of corporate name does not defeat suit; court should substitute correct corporate name and remit for trial.
  • Civil procedure — Order 14A RSC — summary determination of question of law; Companies law — change of name does not affect rights or render proceedings defective; Locus standi — proper corporate party and substitution/joinder; High Court inherent jurisdiction to substitute parties rather than dismiss for misjoinder.
14 December 2020
Persons who assume control of trust property can be held personally liable; claims against seized goods must be lodged within five days.
  • Trusts and trustees — trustee de son tort — personal liability for assuming control of trust property; Execution of judgment — writ of fifa — validity of execution against persons who assumed trustee functions; Civil procedure — Order 42 High Court Rules — interpleader/claims against goods seized by Sheriff — five-day claim period; Corporate personality — separate legal entity of registered trustees; Proof of ownership — brand certificates and timeliness of claims.
10 December 2020
A renewed application permits new matters; Order 33/3 cannot be invoked independently of Order 14A RSC.
  • Civil procedure — preliminary issue — Order 33/3 RSC not stand-alone; must be read with Order 14A — renewal v. appeal — renewal allows fresh matters.
8 December 2020
In a renewed injunction application, the court held new aspects permissible and dismissed the preliminary objection.
  • Civil procedure — Court of Appeal — Preliminary objection — Order 33(3) RSC not standalone; must be read with Order 14A — Distinction between renewal and appeal — New material permissible in renewal — Preliminary objection dismissed.
8 December 2020
The appellant's challenge to the Registrar's registration was dismissed for lack of goodwill and insufficient evidence of public confusion.
  • Company names — Registrar’s discretion under s.37(3) — likelihood of confusion — passing off — requirement of goodwill — sufficiency of evidence of confusion (unproven misdelivery) — distinguishing features in composite names.
6 December 2020