|
Citation
|
Judgment date
|
| December 1938 |
|
|
Whether a township management board owed a duty to fence an old gravel pit where a licensee fell while using a native track.
Township law – definition of "street" and footway; highway by dedication or prescription; occupier's duty to licensee limited to warning of concealed danger; Quarry (Fencing) Act – proximity requirement; Mining Proclamation inapplicability; Townships Regulations non-retrospective/permits only.
|
31 December 1938 |
|
The Credit Sales to Natives Ordinance renders non‑certified credit contracts unenforceable in Northern Rhodesia; lex fori governs enforcement.
Credit Sales to Natives Ordinance – statutory formalities – absence of District Officer’s certificate renders contract unenforceable (not void) in Northern Rhodesia – lex fori governs enforceability – Leroux v. Brown applied.
|
31 December 1938 |
|
Conviction under s.82(b) requires an inducement within the Territory; recruitment abroad precludes liability and conviction was quashed.
Employment of Natives Ordinance – s.82(a) and (b) – liability under s.82(b) requires prior inducement to proceed beyond the Territory – recruitment conducted abroad (outside Territory) precludes conviction under s.82.
|
31 December 1938 |
|
Subordinate Court III lacked jurisdiction to try murder; summary manslaughter convictions quashed and retrial ordered.
Criminal procedure — Subordinate Court (Class III) — lack of jurisdiction to try murder (s.7(2) Criminal Procedure Code) — improper summary adjudication under s.210 — excess of jurisdiction — proceedings null and void — convictions quashed — retrial ordered; irregularities in preliminary inquiry.
|
31 December 1938 |
|
Making false plates and riding in the stolen car made the respondent an accessory before the fact.
Theft — motor car — accessory before the fact — abetment by preparatory acts (selection, false number plates, participation) — presence at moment of removal not required — Penal Code s.21(b).
|
31 December 1938 |
|
Conviction for kidnapping upheld where servant lacked informed consent to removal beyond the Territory.
Criminal law – Kidnapping – Penal Code s.223 – Essential element: absence of informed consent to conveyance beyond Territory – Consent must be deliberate and informed – Silence or passive acquiescence insufficient – Evidence of assault beyond border admissible to explain continuous offence.
|
31 December 1938 |
|
A magistrate must state the charge and record the accused's plea before summarily adjudicating under section 210.
Criminal procedure — Preliminary inquiry — Amendment of charge from murder to manslaughter — Subordinate Court exercising s210 powers must state charge and call for plea per Part VI — Failure to record plea not necessarily fatal — No summary jurisdiction over manslaughter.
|
31 December 1938 |
|
Special finding of "guilty but insane" quashed where insanity at time of offence was not proved; conviction upheld and remitted for sentencing.
Criminal law – Insanity defence – Penal Code s.13 and McNaughton rules – Special finding "guilty but insane" – Indeterminate detention – Review quashing special finding for lack of proof at time of offence.
|
31 December 1938 |
|
Article 3(6) was directory and cannot sustain criminal convictions under Penal Code section 107.
Administrative law – Order in Council – Article 3(6) directory not penal – Criminal liability requires clear statutory basis – Penal Code s.107 (disobedience of statutory duty) inapplicable here – Public concern requirement for s.107 doubtful.
|
31 December 1938 |
|
Court reduced excessive aggregate imprisonment for multiple small-value thefts by a repeat offender to seven years six months.
Criminal law – Sentencing discretion – Multiple convictions – Concurrent and consecutive sentences – Reduction of excessive aggregate term for repeat offender.
|
31 December 1938 |
|
Article 3(6) of the Order in Council is directory, not a criminal provision; convictions under s.107 were quashed.
Administrative law – Crown Lands and Native Reserves (Tanganyika District) Order in Council 1929, Art 3(6) – directory not penal; Penal Code s.107 (disobedience of statutory duty) – inapplicable where duty is not criminal or matter of public concern; convictions quashed.
|
31 December 1938 |
|
Altering and tendering an out-of-date tax receipt as current constitutes uttering under Penal Code section 317, conviction upheld.
Penal Code s.317 – Uttering a document the operation of which has ceased by effluxion of time – Altered native tax receipt – False document – Appropriate charge versus forgery (s.316) or making alteration (s.312).
|
31 December 1938 |
|
A deportation warrant must contain a clear operative command specifying the period; mere recital of a recommendation is insufficient.
Deportation law – validity of deportation warrant – operative command must specify duration – recitals insufficient to prove period – Governor’s discretion over recommendations; form language ("warrant" v. "order") can cause confusion.
|
31 December 1938 |
|
A 12‑month hard‑labour sentence for an unplanned escape was deemed excessive and reduced to three months on review.
Criminal law – Escape from lawful custody (Penal Code s.101) – Sentence severity and proper punishment under s.40 – Unplanned escape by a person of low intelligence – Role of prison authority’s extramural employment – Reduction of sentence on review.
|
31 December 1938 |