All courts

10,041 judgments
  • Filters
  • Judges
  • Topics
  • Alphabet
Sort by:
10,041 judgments
Citation
Judgment date
April 2026
Respondent’s failure to enact Article 60(4) political-party legislation is unconstitutional; Respondent ordered to legislate within 12 months.
Constitutional duty to legislate – Article 60(4) – political parties regulation – justiciability of omissions – Societies Act read-in conformity with Constitution – enforceability of Articles 45 and 60(2) – separation of powers and remedies
2 April 2026
Court ordered respondents to convene arbitral tribunal after they failed to act under the constitution’s arbitration clause.
Arbitration Act s.12(4)(a) — Court powers to secure appointment of arbitrator where party fails to act; FAZ Constitution Article 63 — arbitration for disputes affecting clubs; urgent intervention to protect participation rights in ongoing competition
2 April 2026
Court confirmed stay of provisional liquidator appointment, finding jurisdiction due to special circumstances and procedural irregularities.
Corporate insolvency — Provisional liquidator — Ex parte appointment without return date — Breach of Companies (Winding‑Up) Rules (Rule 8(3)) — Jurisdiction of Court of Appeal to grant first‑instance relief under Order 59 RSC on special circumstances — Stay of execution — Abuse of process and multiplicity of actions
1 April 2026
March 2026
Appellate court affirms Registrar's weighing of expert evidence but awards nominal sums for redundancy and inducement where quantum was unproven.
Civil procedure — assessment of damages after appellate findings of liability; Expert evidence — weight, admissibility and advisory role; Damages — remoteness, foreseeability, mitigation, and when nominal awards appropriate; Tort — inducing breach of contract; Inventory treatment in loss-of-profits calculations
31 March 2026
Court granted bail pending appeal due to exceptional circumstances: arguable appeal and risk of serving sentence before determination.
Criminal procedure – Bail pending appeal – Exceptional circumstances required – Prima facie prospects of success – Risk of serving sentence before appeal heard – Manslaughter: gross negligence, duty of care, causation
31 March 2026
Whether challenges to a public body's suspension must be by judicial review or may proceed by writ when broader claims require full trial.
Civil procedure — Mode of commencement: writ of summons versus judicial review; leave requirement for judicial review; pleadings' scope (contracts, damages, historical conduct) determines appropriate procedure under Order 6 Rule 1; courts may assess pleadings' content without adjudicating non-party interests
31 March 2026
Attainment of retirement age without giving required notice does not constitute retirement, so payroll retention and post‑retirement benefits fail.
Employment law – retirement age and notice requirements; Interpretation of by‑laws (S.I. No. 2 of 1995) and effect of S.I
No. 46 of 2019; Article 189(2)
Constitution – retention on payroll limited to pension benefits under pension law; distinction between retrenchment and pension benefits; counterclaim – delay in remedy and failure to recover from terminal benefits disentitles employer
31 March 2026
Conviction for theft quashed where prosecution failed to prove taking or fraudulent intent and trial court relied on speculation.
Criminal law — Theft: elements of theft (taking/movement, fraudulent intent, absence of claim of right) — Burden of proof beyond reasonable doubt — Administrative acts (requisitioning/stock control) do not amount to taking absent movement or fraud — Trial judge must give reasoned judgment and not convict on speculation — Adverse inference from alleged 'volunteer' status improper without evidence
31 March 2026
The court upheld the respondent's chieftainship, favoring documentary recognition and community acquiescence over competing oral claims.
Chieftainship succession; customary law; Kojo v Bonsie evidential test; documentary contemporaneous records v oral tradition; matrilineal succession; administrative recognition; adequacy of judicial reasoning
31 March 2026
Failure to notify the appellant of a Director's decision precludes statutory appeal; High Court may hear the trespass action.
Mines and Minerals Development Act — sections 96 and 97 — mandatory written notice, reasons and right of appeal — failure to notify precludes invoking 30‑day appeal — jurisdiction and mode of commencement — trespass action vs statutory appeal — remit to High Court
31 March 2026
A legal practitioner who withdraws and dissipates client funds without authorization breaches a strict fiduciary duty and may be struck off.
Professional misconduct — failure to account — client trust funds — unauthorized withdrawal and transfer — strict fiduciary duty under Legal Practitioners Act and Practice Rules — striking off as sanction
31 March 2026
Challenge to sequencing of delimitation and voter registration dismissed; delimitation disputes governed by Article 58(7) and no required sequence exists.
Constitutional law — delimitation of constituencies — Article 58(7) special review mechanism; delimitation need not precede voter registration; Act No.13/2025 increases constituencies; ripeness/prematurity of constitutional challenges; independence of Electoral Management Body
30 March 2026
Plaintiffs failed to prove the Extraordinary General Conference or election were invalid; claim dismissed and each party bears own costs.
Political party governance — validity of Extraordinary General Conference and election — compliance with party constitution and regulations — evidential burden and proof — internal party electoral regulations not produced — constitutional challenge (Article 60(2)) falls to Constitutional Court.
27 March 2026
Whether the respondent's capacity to sue after revocation of the statutory order must be decided before trial.
:[
26 March 2026
Post-award tort claims for trespass and conversion were not barred by a prior arbitration award and are remitted to trial.
Res judicata – whether prior arbitral award bars later tort claims; abuse of court process; arbitration clause scope and separability; post-award tortious claims for trespass and conversion; duty to raise claims with reasonable diligence
26 March 2026
Failure to cite enabling law was not fatal; access and maintenance orders upheld as in the child’s best interests.
Procedure—Practice Direction/non-compliance—jurisdiction; Family law—Children’s Code Act—best interests; Access—meaningful contact vs. restricted hours; Maintenance—assessment of means, quantum and effective date; Arrears—requirement for clear pleadings and documentary proof; Appellate review—interference only for perversity/misdirection or material misapplication of discretion
26 March 2026
Appeal against a twenty‑year murder sentence dismissed; child evidence expunged and sentence altered to imprisonment with hard labour.
Criminal law – murder – provocation as failed defence amounting to extenuating circumstances – children's evidence and proper voir dire under Children’s Code – competence of DPP appeal on sentencing principles – sentence alteration to hard labour.
26 March 2026
Whether similarly circumstanced employees can be joined to execute an old Industrial Relations judgment despite limitation periods.
Industrial Relations Act s85(6) – joinder of similarly circumstanced employees; Limitation Act 1939 ss2(1) and 2(4) – time limits for actions and execution of judgments; consent order and revival of limitation; finality of litigation
26 March 2026
Court of Appeal found a subsisting crop‑finance contract, upheld Respondent's admitted indebtedness, and remitted assessment to the Registrar.
Contract formation – totality of evidence; admissibility of non-original/scanned documents once foundation laid; confirmation of debt as admissible admission; signature discrepancies not necessarily fatal; assessment of outstanding contractual indebtedness by Registrar; interest at 1% above SOFR
25 March 2026
Appellant's failure to comply with Industrial Relations Division procedure and to show sufficient cause warranted dismissal of appeal.
Industrial Relations Division procedure — setting aside judgment obtained in absence — sufficiency of cause — applicability of High Court/English Rules — affidavit of service — legal effect of ex parte endorsement.
25 March 2026
An issue not raised below cannot be raised on appeal; Industrial Relations Court may overlook technical defaults under section 85(5).
Industrial relations jurisdiction – Procedural defaults – Whether issues not raised below may be raised on appeal – Filing of answer and leave to file out of time – Section 85(5) Industrial Relations Rules (flexible equitable jurisdiction) – Evidence of service as commencement of limitation.
25 March 2026
Whether non‑implementation of statutory climate mechanisms constitutes a justiciable constitutional violation.
Constitutional law — Article 257(g) duty to address climate change — Green Economy and Climate Change Act (GECCA) — IMRV System, Climate Change Fund, Climate Change Register — statutory compliance vs. constitutional question — jurisdiction and justiciability — referral under Article 128(2).
25 March 2026
Where dismissal follows an unless order not proved served, a court may review and restore the matter to do substantial justice.
Civil procedure – unless orders and dismissal for non-compliance – effect of non-service of notice – court’s power to review its own final order to do substantial justice – ex parte review and natural justice – procedural technicalities not fatal
25 March 2026
Conviction unsafe where mental incapacity not proved; medical evidence required in borderline cases.
Criminal law – Defilement of an imbecile – Proof of mental illness/imbecility – Requirement of medical evidence in borderline cases – Admissibility of lay/ocular evidence to prove incapacity – Knowledge element under Section 139 Penal Code
25 March 2026
Preliminary issues involving disputed facts under Order 33/3 are not suitable for summary determination under Order 14A; appeal dismissed.
Civil procedure – Order 14A RSC – summary determination of questions of law; Order 33/3 RSC – preliminary issues of fact or law to be tried; distinction between summary disposal and trial/inquiry; statutory qualification and illegality under the Zambia Institute of Architects Act; jurisdiction to hear claims tainted by alleged illegality.
25 March 2026
An equitable mortgage may be recognised from parties' clear intention despite non‑registration, permitting foreclosure and conveyance.
Equitable mortgage — created by deposit of title deeds or by parties' agreement/intention — effect of non‑registration — foreclosure and conveyance — equity regards as done that which ought to be done.
25 March 2026
A surviving spouse beneficiary has locus standi to sue over intestate property; court ordered the estate administrator be joined.
Intestate succession; surviving spouse’s interest in matrimonial property; locus standi of beneficiaries; reasonable cause of action; constructive trust defence; joinder of estate administrator; costs follow the event.
25 March 2026
Whether party suspensions lapse after twelve months and whether the acting secretary-general had locus standi to sue.
Party law – disciplinary procedure – suspension limited to 12 months – effluxion of time; representative actions – locus standi and common interest; Order 14A/Order 33 summary disposal; costs follow the event.
25 March 2026
A trust deed made during divorce cannot defeat adjustment; matrimonial property may be sold and proceeds divided between spouses.
Family law – property adjustment between spouses – trust deed executed during or after divorce – timing and intention relevant; contributions in kind and by familial role recognized; encumbrance raised on appeal unsupported by documents.
25 March 2026
An MP’s imprisonment automatically vacates the seat; an appeal does not suspend the vacancy or by-election timeline.
Constitutional law — Parliamentary privilege limited to proceedings; Imprisonment disqualifies MP under Art 70(2)(f) and vacates seat under Art 72(2)(b); pending appeal does not suspend vacancy or by-election timelines; Article 128 references decided on the referring court’s record; Chilangwa affirmed.
25 March 2026
Part payments and acknowledgements reset limitation; credit notes compensated defects so damages were set aside.
Limitation Act s23(4) – acknowledgement/part payment restarts limitation; Sale of Goods Act s14 – implied fitness for purpose requires known particular purpose and reliance; credit notes as compensation; prevention of double recovery; debt assessment and costs.
25 March 2026
Contract expired by effluxion of time; no implied extension; damages upheld but payment under guarantee set aside to avoid unjust enrichment.
Contract law — effluxion of time v implied extension by conduct; specific performance requires subsisting contract; advance payment guarantees — payment on terms and risk of unjust enrichment; appellate procedure — new issues not raised below inadmissible on appeal
25 March 2026
Appeal dismissed: court held agreed written submissions and clear contract required the appellant to pay VAT; costs awarded.
Contract interpretation – express terms and inadmissibility of extrinsic evidence; Tax law – VAT payable where contract expressly provides + consumer liability; Civil procedure – parties bound by agreed procedure (written submissions); Pleadings – issues not pleaded may be dismissed as afterthoughts; Costs – discretionary award to successful party
25 March 2026
Conviction for defilement unsafe where child’s identification lacked corroboration despite medical evidence of sexual activity.
'Defilement' – Child witness evidence – Corroboration under Section 78(9) Children’s Code Act – Medical evidence corroborates occurrence of sexual activity but not identity – Unsafe conviction where identity not corroborated
25 March 2026
Sale was not by description and misrepresentation was not established; contract remains valid and respondents must pay the invoice price with interest.
Sale of goods — whether sale by description — implied condition as to description — Sale of Goods Act s.13 — FOB pricing and per-ton quotations — misrepresentation — rescission — proof of special damages and transport costs — contractual allocation of carriage.
25 March 2026
Possession order set aside where court-ordered resurvey was not properly conducted or analysed, remitting matter for a compliant resurvey.
Land law – resurvey versus boundary verification – compliance with court-ordered resurvey – natural justice and right to be heard before dispossession – inadmissibility of execution based on verification relying on defective survey diagrams
25 March 2026
Whether the High Court may exercise revisionary powers on appeal and the effect of an improperly recorded plea on forfeiture orders.
Criminal procedure — Revisionary jurisdiction vs appellate jurisdiction — Sections 337 and 338 Criminal Procedure Code — Prohibition on review where convicted person has appealed; Plea procedure — accused represented by counsel; dealing with disputed facts; consequences of improperly taken plea; Conviction‑based forfeiture — requires valid conviction and proper nexus
25 March 2026
Court reduced the appellant's 22-year manslaughter sentence to 4 years, finding insufficient aggravating factors.
Criminal law – Manslaughter – sentencing – manifestly excessive sentence – aggravating factors – place of assault – internal head injury (subdural haematoma) – appellate interference under Court of Appeal Act
25 March 2026
A non‑party cannot be joined to challenge an executed consent judgment absent an appeal or application for review.
Civil procedure — Joinder after judgment — Consent judgment — Functus officio — Post‑judgment joinder permissible only where there is an appeal or review — Locus standi and sufficient interest required for joinder.
25 March 2026
A sanctioned scheme binds only statutory creditors with enforceable debts; pending contested claims do not oust appellate jurisdiction.
Corporate Insolvency Act – Scheme of Arrangement – effect of sanction – binding on creditors as defined by statute; jurisdictional objections may be raised at any time; pending/unascertained claims are not 'creditors' under scheme.
24 March 2026
The Court of Appeal upheld calculation of terminal benefits under the written contract, ordered NAPSA refund, and dismissed the appeal.
Employment law – written contract governs terminal benefits; gratuity calculated on agreed exit salary; unremitted pension (NAPSA) contributions refundable; Employment Code applicable where termination occurred after its commencement.
24 March 2026
Writ of summons was proper for mixed Companies Act claims; case remitted for full determination on the merits.
Companies Act — mode of commencement — writ of summons v originating summons — multiplicity of actions — jurisdiction — appellate restraint where trial court made no findings of fact — minority shareholder remedies; account of profits; oppressive conduct.
20 March 2026
Whether a purported contract renewal by a former secondee bound the respondent and if trial findings were plainly wrong.
Contract law – authority and capacity to bind principal; agency/secondment – limits on authority of former secondee; validity of purported contract renewals; indoor management/Turquand rule – inapplicability where principal notified of non-renewal; appellate review – deference to trial court factual findings (plainly wrong standard).
20 March 2026
An appeal from a judgment delivered in chambers is incompetent without leave under section 23(1)(e) of the Court of Appeal Act.
Appeal procedure — requirement of leave to appeal from judgments delivered in chambers — Court of Appeal Act s.23(1)(e); Competency of appeal — failure to obtain leave is incurable; Civil procedure — originating summons under Order 113 RSC for summary possession of land; Effect of cancelled mining licences on possession (decided in lower court but not considered on appeal).
20 March 2026
Applicant's challenge to removal as Ngoni chief dismissed; paramount chief's customary authority upheld.
:[
19 March 2026
Whether Article 76 parliamentary privilege protects media statements made within National Assembly precincts.
Constitutional jurisdiction – Article 128(2) referral obligation; Parliamentary privilege – Article 76 freedom of speech limited to formal proceedings; Press briefings and media statements within precincts not protected; Justiciability of internal parliamentary matters.
19 March 2026
A commitment letter during ongoing negotiations did not create a binding contract; claims were dismissed.
Contract formation — Commitment letters/letters of intent — Intention to create legal relations — Certainty of essential terms — Consideration — Proof of special damages for loss of business.
13 March 2026
High Court erred by deciding a petition not before it and failing to rule on the applicant's stay application.
Constitutional law — parliamentary privilege and alleged immunity from criminal prosecution; Civil procedure — jurisdiction and competence to decide matters not formally before the court; Procedural fairness — judge’s misdirection in deciding unargued issues; Remittal to cure failure to determine application heard.
13 March 2026
Plaintiffs proved false imprisonment and are awarded damages, but failed to prove malicious prosecution for lack of malice.
Malicious prosecution — elements: prosecution, favorable termination, absence of reasonable and probable cause, malice; False imprisonment — unlawful arrest, burden of proof; Damages — general, aggravated, exemplary; Effect of defendant's default on burden of proof.
11 March 2026
Specific performance granted only for available 2-acre title; assignments lodged during a subsisting caveat were irregular, and the balance refunded with interest.
Property law – contract of sale – extent of land sold – caveat effect – entries made during subsistence of caveat irregular; Limitation – land actions 12-year period; Specific performance – discretionary remedy and cannot affect rights of unjoined third-party title holders; Alternative damages – court must choose appropriate remedy.
11 March 2026