Results.
231 judgments found.
|
|
|
| December 2022 |
|
|
Retention of counsel is prima facie good ground to allow the appellant to retract an unrepresented guilty plea before sentencing.
-
Criminal procedure — Retraction of guilty plea before sentence — Discretion to allow withdrawal on good and sufficient grounds — Retention/change of counsel as prima facie good ground; Criminal procedure — Duplicity of charges — Charging under s87(4) and s130(2)(a) in a single count contrary to s135(2) CPC; Zambia Wildlife Act — possession of prescribed trophy.
|
8 December 2022 |
|
Registrar properly exercised discretion; appellants lacked goodwill and evidence of confusion to justify deregistration.
-
Company names — Registrar's discretion under s.37(3) Companies Act — likelihood of confusion — passing‑off and goodwill — evidentiary requirement for market confusion; de‑registration remedy.
|
7 December 2022 |
|
Trafficking elements not proved; conviction substituted for attempt to smuggle persons under Anti-Human Trafficking Act.
-
Anti-Human Trafficking Act — definition and elements of ‘trafficking’ — requirement of specified means and purpose of exploitation; smuggling of persons — elements require successful illegal entry/exit for financial gain; attempt — liability where means and intent shown though act not completed.
|
7 December 2022 |
|
Trafficking requires proof of specified means and exploitation; evidence established attempted smuggling, not trafficking.
-
Anti-Human Trafficking Act — definition and elements of "trafficking" — requirement to prove prescribed means and purpose of exploitation; Distinction between trafficking and smuggling; Smuggling of persons — elements: illegal entry/exit and financial gain; Attempt to smuggle — liability under section 12; Substitution of conviction on appeal.
|
7 December 2022 |
|
|
7 December 2022 |
|
Fraud in issuance of a land title must be proved and attributed to the offeree; absent such proof, statutory protection of title prevails.
-
Conveyancing and land titles — Allegation of fraud in acquisition of Certificate of Title — Proof required to vitiate title — Effect of section 33 Lands and Deeds Registry Act — Evidence of altered survey/layout plans not sufficient without attribution of fraud.
|
6 December 2022 |
|
Summary dismissal requires adherence to disciplinary procedure and natural justice; damages upheld, costs order set aside.
-
Employment law — Summary dismissal — Employer must follow disciplinary rules and natural justice — Formal charge and hearing required — Evidence and admissibility of out-of-court statement — Measure of damages for unfair dismissal (departure from notice-period rule) — Costs: when to award.
|
6 December 2022 |
|
Summary dismissal requires disciplinary process and hearing; absent proven admission, dismissal was unlawful, damages upheld, costs set aside.
-
Employment law — Summary dismissal — Requirement to follow employer's disciplinary rules and afford hearing; Admission/confession — evidential requirements; Damages for unfair dismissal — departure from normal measure; Costs in industrial relations cases — need for stated basis.
|
6 December 2022 |
|
Whether a temporary occupant can be a legal sitting tenant and whether an irregularly obtained title must be cancelled.
-
Government pool houses — sitting tenant eligibility and allocation slips — temporary occupation vs legal sitting tenant — irregular issuance and cancellation of certificate of title — preparation of title pursuant to partial payment offer.
|
6 December 2022 |
| November 2022 |
|
|
A trial court cannot decide issues not before it; equitable mortgage protects title deed holder and mortgagee who sells must account after conveyance.
-
Mortgage law — foreclosure vs sale; equitable mortgage by deposit of title deed; functus officio — trial court cannot decide new issues after judgment; mortgagee’s duty to account for surplus after completed sale; foreclosure nisi not automatically absolute.
|
25 November 2022 |
|
Appellant's challenge to a third-party mortgage failed: documents showed a mortgagor security, no bank misrepresentation, appeal dismissed.
-
Banking law — construction of facility letters and guarantees — mortgagor versus surety — misrepresentation and duty to advise — third party mortgage validity — foreclosure remedy.
|
25 November 2022 |
|
Appellate court dismissed appellant's premature jurisdictional challenge to possession proceedings based on alleged invalid letters of administration.
-
Civil procedure — jurisdictional challenge — letters of administration — Local Court jurisdiction to grant administration — certificate of title conclusive (Lands and Deeds Registry Act s.33) — premature appellate intervention on factual issues.
|
22 November 2022 |
|
Failure to obtain leave for a second appeal after High Court review deprived the Court of Appeal of jurisdiction.
-
Criminal appeals — Jurisdiction of Court of Appeal — Court of Appeal Act ss.14 & 15 — Distinction between first and second appeals — High Court exercise of review powers when confirming subordinate court sentence — Leave to appeal required for second appeals — Appeal struck out for want of jurisdiction.
|
18 November 2022 |
|
Daylight identification upheld but murder conviction substituted for manslaughter where no proof the appellant delivered the fatal blow.
-
Criminal law — identification evidence — discrepancies not fatal where attack in daylight and witnesses had adequate opportunity to observe; Criminal law — mob/collective violence — murder requires proof accused inflicted fatal blow; participation in mob may support manslaughter not murder.
|
17 November 2022 |
|
Conviction based solely on 'last seen' evidence and a minor contradiction is unsafe without supporting circumstantial proof.
-
Criminal law — Circumstantial evidence — 'Last seen' theory — Time lapse and accused’s explanation material — Minor contradictions insufficient to anchor conviction — Conviction unsafe where alternative inferences equally plausible.
|
17 November 2022 |
|
Provocation during a mutual fight can reduce murder to manslaughter where retaliation is proportionate in the heat of the moment.
-
Criminal law — provocation (Section 205 Penal Code) — heat of passion — proportionality assessed in context of a mutual fight — murder reduced to manslaughter — sentence substituted.
|
17 November 2022 |
|
Single-witness identification, recent possession and ballistic evidence together upheld conviction and sentence.
-
Criminal law — Identification by single witness — need to exclude honest mistake; Recent possession doctrine — inference of guilt from recovery of stolen goods; Ballistic and physical evidence corroboration; Suspect witness — when independent physical evidence obviates need for corroboration.
|
16 November 2022 |
|
Appeal dismissed: conviction for stock theft upheld where accomplice evidence was corroborated by identification and admission.
-
Criminal law — Stock theft — Accomplice/co-accused evidence — Corroboration requirement — Single identifying witness — Reliability of night identification — Admission of sale as corroborative evidence.
|
16 November 2022 |
|
Appellate court reduced a manifestly excessive 15-year mob‑justice manslaughter sentence imposed on the appellant to five years.
-
Criminal law — Manslaughter — Mob justice during gassing panic — Sentencing principles — Appellate interference where sentence is wrong in principle or manifestly excessive — Concurrent substitution to five years.
|
16 November 2022 |
|
Four appellants convicted of aggravated robbery (reclassified from armed robbery); one appellant acquitted; death sentences set aside.
-
Criminal law — Aggravated robbery — identification evidence and CCTV corroboration — single identifying witness; recent possession of stolen property as connecting link; odd coincidences as corroboration; distinction between armed aggravated robbery (firearm use) and ordinary aggravated robbery; failure to lift fingerprints and dereliction of police duty; appellate review of credibility findings.
|
15 November 2022 |
|
A General List judge lacked jurisdiction to decide transfer of a commercial action; transfer applications must be determined by a Commercial List judge.
-
Commercial Division — Order LIII High Court Rules — Definition of commercial action — Transfer to Commercial List — Jurisdiction of General List judge vs. Commercial List judge — Banker‑customer disputes; fraud and negligence in commercial transactions
|
11 November 2022 |
|
Application to set aside dismissal for want of prosecution refused due to inordinate unexplained delay in filing Record of Appeal.
-
Court of Appeal Rules — setting aside dismissal for want of prosecution — inordinate delay and failure to prosecute — Record of Appeal not filed — absence of evidence of efforts to obtain proceedings — Notice of Address of Service not material.
|
11 November 2022 |
|
Bankruptcy proceedings founded on a judgment are "an action" under the Limitation Act 1939 and may be time-barred.
-
Limitation Act 1939 s.2(4) — meaning of "action" — insolvency/bankruptcy proceedings fall within "action"; Bankruptcy Act (Ch.82) s.163(4) — continuation of English 1952 Bankruptcy Rules; Rule 129 — security for costs and court’s discretion to dispense.
|
4 November 2022 |
|
Cancellation of titles upheld for procedural impropriety despite fraud not proved; appeal dismissed.
-
Land law — Allocation of state land — Procedural impropriety and missing application files — Cancellation of Certificates of Title under s.34 Lands and Deeds Registry Act — Pleadings and evidence — Reversion of title to State.
|
4 November 2022 |
|
Expiry of a fixed-term contract without assurances does not create a legitimate expectation of renewal; unpleaded relief cannot ground damages.
-
Labour/employment law — fixed-term contracts — effluxion of time — legitimate expectation requires a promise or assurance — courts should not award relief based on unpleaded claims; appellate relief and costs.
|
1 November 2022 |
| October 2022 |
|
|
Whether the appellant’s correspondence and payment agreement constituted a clear admission, negating a condition precedent, justifying judgment on admission.
-
Commercial law — judgment on admission — clear and unequivocal admission via agreement and correspondence — condition precedent — adequacy of defence — discretion to enter judgment on admission.
|
28 October 2022 |
|
Appeal dismissed for incompetence due to omission of mandatory record documents and improper certification of the record.
-
Civil procedure — Record of appeal — Mandatory compliance with Order X rule 9(5) and Order 10 — omission of order granting leave, memorandum of appeal, affidavits and exhibits — improper certification by non‑originating registrar — supplementary record requires formal leave within 14 days — appeal dismissed for incompetence.
|
26 October 2022 |
|
Committee resolution, valuation and ministerial communication established council approval; appeal dismissed and tenant entitled to purchase plot.
-
Local Government Act — delegated committee authority — section 35(1),(4) and 36 — committee discharge deemed council action; ministerial approval — written direction by ministry official suffices; valuation procured and relied on by purchaser — outsider reliance on council agents; unwilling‑vendor principle; entitlement of sitting tenant to purchase land.
|
26 October 2022 |
|
The appellant's appeal was dismissed for being filed out of time; the stay of execution was refused.
-
Court of Appeal — Appeal time limits — Section 25 Court of Appeal Act and Order X Rule 3(5) Court of Appeal Rules — mandatory 30-day filing period — dismissal for filing out of time — stay of execution pending appeal fails when appeal dismissed.
|
26 October 2022 |
|
A certificate of title is conclusive unless fraud is clearly pleaded and proved; the applicant failed to prove prior interest or notice.
-
Property law — Registered title under the Lands and Deeds Registry Act s.33 — Conclusive effect of Certificate of Title; challenging title for fraud requires clear, distinct pleadings and proof; locus standi of a non-party to a contract; evidential weight of audio recordings and burden to prove payment/consideration in land transactions.
|
25 October 2022 |
|
Respondent's request for extension to file a preliminary objection denied for insufficient justification and unjustified delay.
-
Court of Appeal rules — Order XIII Rule 5(1) — fourteen‑day notice for preliminary objections — Order XIII Rule 3 discretion to extend time — sufficiency of reasons — delay due to awaiting instructions not acceptable where objection is legal in nature.
|
21 October 2022 |
|
Appellate court affirmed no proof of loan disbursement, rejected burden-shift claim, reversed equitable mortgage finding, and dismissed appeal.
-
Evidence and proof — alleged disbursement of loan and burden of proof; Fraud/misrepresentation — pleading and standard of proof; Credibility findings — appellate deference to trial judge; Equitable mortgage — deposit of title deeds, requirement of consideration and presumption rebuttable only where consideration established.
|
14 October 2022 |
|
Arrest based on reasonable suspicion, but unlawful detention beyond 24 hours warranted damages for three days.
-
Criminal procedure — Arrest on reasonable suspicion (s.26 CPC) — Detention and requirement to bring accused before court within 24 hours (s.33 CPC) — False imprisonment/damages for unlawful prolonged detention — Separate legal personality of company — Proof of loss and agency issues.
|
9 October 2022 |
|
Appellant owed activation bonuses and revenue share; amounts remitted for assessment; admitted sum entered; counterclaim to be assessed and set‑off applied.
-
Contract law — Distributor agreement — activation bonuses and 2% revenue share — liquidated demand v special damages; failure to produce monthly sales performance reports; duty to prove quantum; assessment by Registrar where liability shown but quantum uncertain; counterclaim for dishonoured cheques and set‑off; costs — parties to bear their own costs.
|
6 October 2022 |
| September 2022 |
|
|
Conviction under the death‑penalty provision cannot stand where particulars did not clearly allege use of a statutory "firearm."
-
Criminal law — aggravated robbery — distinction between Section 294(1) and 294(2) — requirement to notify accused of firearm use and potential death sentence — construction of "gun" versus statutory "firearm" — Section 181 CPC and conviction on uncharged offences.
|
28 September 2022 |
|
Appeal dismissed: committal to High Court lawful, single-witness recognition reliable, firearm proved, death sentences upheld.
-
Criminal procedure — preliminary inquiry and DPP certificate of committal; Identification — single witness recognition and dangers of mistaken identity; Aggravated/armed robbery — proof of firearm (ballistics) and notice in particulars; Sentence — mandatory death under s.294(2) where firearm used.
|
28 September 2022 |
|
Equitable mortgage may subsist despite unregistered legal mortgage; counter-claim must be heard together with main action.
-
Lands and Deeds Registry Act — late registration renders legal mortgage void but equitable mortgage may arise by deposit/possession of title deeds; Order 30 r.14 HCR — mortgage actions by originating summons; Order 28 RSC/Order 15 RSC — counter-claims in originating summons; severance of counter-claim; discretion as to mode of commencement.
|
27 September 2022 |
|
Leave granted for judicial review of tender cancellation on arguable public-law ground that the Permanent Secretary exceeded statutory authority.
-
Judicial review — leave to apply — public procurement — authority to cancel tenders — Zambia Wildlife Act vs Permanent Secretary — illegality, procedural impropriety and irrationality — exhaustion of administrative remedies — limited stay of invitation for bids (Chikwa Hunting Block).
|
27 September 2022 |
|
Whether a Permanent Secretary could lawfully cancel awarded hunting-concession tenders when statutory authority vests in the Wildlife Management Licensing Committee.
-
Judicial review — leave to apply — statutory authority to cancel tenders — Zambia Wildlife Act and Public Procurement Act — powers of Wildlife Management Licensing Committee vs Permanent Secretary — exhaustion of administrative remedies — interim stay limited to affected concession.
|
27 September 2022 |
|
Leave granted for judicial review of a tender cancellation where the Permanent Secretary allegedly acted outside statutory authority.
-
Judicial review — leave to apply — public law v private law — statutory allocation of decision‑making under Zambia Wildlife Act — Wildlife Management Licensing Committee as procurement/licensing entity — Public Procurement Act (cancellation, notification) — exhaustion of administrative remedies — limited stay of proceedings.
|
27 September 2022 |
|
Appeal: malice established; trial court misdirected on provocation—conviction reduced to manslaughter and seven-year sentence imposed.
-
Criminal law — Murder vs manslaughter — constructive malice; provocation as partial defence; self-defence — imminence and proportionality; appellate review of contradictory factual findings.
|
23 September 2022 |
|
Single-witness identification unsafe where alleged connecting link is hearsay and investigative dereliction raises reasonable doubt.
-
Criminal law — identification evidence — single identifying witness — opportunity for observation — danger of mistaken identity; Connecting link — admissibility of statements by uncalled witness — hearsay; Investigative failures — failure to lift fingerprints/collect phone records — dereliction of duty — presumption favouring accused; Recent possession doctrine — requires corroboration where identification is weak.
|
23 September 2022 |
|
Recent possession of stolen goods justified an inference of guilt; prejudicial prisoner-status evidence was expunged but appeal dismissed.
-
Criminal law — aggravated robbery — circumstantial evidence and recent possession; identification parades — missing photographs and pre-parade contact; inadmissible prejudicial evidence of prisoner status — expunged but no resultant unfairness.
|
23 September 2022 |
|
Disciplinary procedure breaches rendered dismissal wrongful despite lack of proven discrimination; six months' salary awarded.
-
Employment law — wrongful dismissal — procedural fairness and compliance with employer's disciplinary code; discrimination claims by lawfully dismissed employee; seniority and stiffer penalties; assessment of damages and costs under Industrial and Labour Relations Act Rule 44(1).
|
15 September 2022 |
|
Applicant's leave application dismissed: no leave required to appeal Industrial Relations Division judgment; applicant may file appeal within 30 days.
-
Court of Appeal Act — appeals — leave to appeal — judgments of Industrial Relations Division — section 23 exclusions; time limit under section 25.
|
15 September 2022 |
|
A single judge may grant leave to appeal where the High Court refused, if reasonable prospects and public importance exist.
-
Court of Appeal — leave to appeal — single judge jurisdiction (Court of Appeal Act s.12(2)) — reasonable prospects of success — public importance — permission to appeal where High Court refused.
|
12 September 2022 |
|
Customary succession requires a joint electoral college meeting; courts cannot impose selection from a specific family.
-
Chieftaincy succession — customary law — matrilineal succession — electoral college (Mbumba) must sit jointly (Jumbe, Mchacha, Chikwanda) — procedural irregularity vitiates selection — court may not impose selection from specific family — post-judgment correction using Supreme Court Rule 78 not competent in High Court matter.
|
8 September 2022 |
|
Whether the Kunda customary electoral process was followed and whether a court may limit eligible families for chieftaincy succession.
-
Customary law — Chieftaincy succession — Requirement that Mbumba (electoral female college) from Jumbe, Mchacha and Chikwanda meet for selection — Matrilineal succession — Invalidity of selection where customary procedure not followed — Courts cannot impose unsupported familial restriction on customary succession.
|
8 September 2022 |
|
Extension of time granted to regularize appeal record after a genuine clerical omission, as respondent suffered no prejudice.
-
Civil procedure — Extension of time — Order XIII Rule 3 — Consent order permitting amended pleadings — Clerical/administrative omission — Sufficient reason — No prejudice — Regularisation of court record — Costs awarded.
|
6 September 2022 |
|
Application to stay third‑party proceedings pending appeal dismissed for lack of good reasons and prospects of success.
-
Civil procedure — Stay of third‑party proceedings pending appeal — Order X Rule 5 Court of Appeal Rules; third‑party proceedings for indemnity and avoidance of multiplicity; requirement of good and sufficient reasons and reasonable prospects of success; no automatic stay on appeal.
|
6 September 2022 |